It’d be fun to have an entry with a part that must be read aloud. So, you know, I say, "Why not now?" Your first task is to read this poem outloud:
- IF women could be fair and yet not fond,
- Or that their love were firm, not fickle still,
- I would not marvel that they make men bond,
- By service long to purchase their good will.
- But when I see how frail those creatures are,
- I muse that men forget themselves so far.
- To mark the choice they make and how they change,
- How oft from Phoebus they do fly to Pan,
- Unsettled still, like haggards wild they range,
- These gentle birds that fly from man to man;
- Who would not scorn, and shake them from the fist,
- And let them fly, fair fools, which way they list?
- Yet for disport we fawn and flatter both,
- To pass the time when nothing else can please;
- And train them to our lure with subtle oath
- Till, weary of their wiles, ourselves we ease;
- And then we say, when we their fancy try,
- To play with fools, oh, what a fool was I!
And then this one:
- Sigh no more, ladies, sigh no more,
- Men were deceivers ever;
- One foot in sea, and one on shore,
- To one thing constant never.
- Then sigh not so,
- But let them go,
- And be you blith and bonny,
- Converting all your sounds of woe
- Into Hey nonny, nonny.
- Sing no more ditties, sing no mo
- Of dumps so dull and heavy;
- The fraud of men was ever so,
- Since summer first was leavy.
- Then sigh not so,
- But let them go,
- And be you blith and bonny,
- Converting all your sounds of woe
- Into Hey nonny, nonny.
Same author?
I keep reading the first one and hearing a lesser poet, too many words when fewer would serve, a man tangled in the rhyme scheme instead of toying with it. But I wonder if that’s my bias, knowing it’s Ed who wrote the first and Will the second.
Still, how often is that argument fought out over and over, that Ed was Will because Will could not possibly have been? And I wonder, do these folks making that argument not read both poets? Can they not hear one ponder where the other plays?
Or is that just my own bias? Rooting for the kid from the countryside?