I caught the Butcher and the Red-Headed Kid watching Snow White and the Huntsman and I sat down and watched them watch it, because, it quickly became apparent they were watching it more like a sport than a movie. They cheered when someone managed some good acting. They cringed when the acting was particularly bad. They did a lot of cringing.
I haven’t watched any of the Twilight movies but I was struck in this one with Kristen Stewart’s amazing blankness. It’s not about her acting. I mean, there are other terrible actors in the world. And, who knows? She might be a fine actor. This just wasn’t the movie for displaying it. She just has this quality of being… I don’t know quite how to explain it. But there’s something about her presence on-screen that encourages you to imagine yourself in her spot. She becomes, somehow, almost not there. There’s just a girl-sized hole where she should be into which the viewer is invited to pour herself.
It’s the damndest thing. And not that I want to watch any of the Twilight movies, but seeing her in this made it easier for me to understand their popularity.
It also made it easier for me to sympathize with her weird relationship with the public in general. I can’t think of another star in my lifetime (or ever, but I’m curious if there’s been another) whose appeal is that she’s like a video game avatar for her public.
I don’t know if I’m quite getting at what I noticed about her. Because it occurs to me that of course a lot of stars are just the public image their fans want and of course a lot of stars are just the fantasies their publicists sell the public. But this is something, it seems to me, beyond that. This isn’t “Imagine if you were Kristen Stewart.” This is her ability (is it an ability? I’m not sure.) to disappear while right in front of you leaving room for you to imagine yourself in her spot–“Imagine if Kristen Stewart were you.”
We treat a lot of our stars like they are characters in movies–or that they are the characters they play in movies. But I do think that Stewart might be the first start so blatantly treated like a video game avatar, as a stand-in for the people who are imagining themselves through her.