Here’s the story of the fourth witch, a woman who was brought before the Inquisition.
“Doña,” they said, “you stand accused of reading cards for broken hearted women and making love potions that are guaranteed to rouse a man’s passions.”
“Yes,” she said. “I do those things, and more, and why should I not, when they work?”
“Excuse me?” they said. “How do you plead?”
“Guilty,” she said. “I do the things you accuse me of.”
A thick silence spread across the room. The torturer looked at the Inquisitors in confusion. The rack, the wheel, the hot irons all were useless. You need not extract a confession from the willing.
Had no one ever pled guilty before?
This is perhaps the most baffling part of the story. How were these men so unprepared to find what they were looking for?
Maybe later they were ready for women like her. Maybe later those women were sent to their deaths anyway.
But it worked once. Admitting what you were worked. And the woman went free.